(718) 387-2281

289 Manhattan Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11211 40.7137 -73.9462

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Williamsburg

Reviews & Ratings for Fortunato Brothers

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/23/09

Great Place!

by chamberdoorzzz

I initially heard about this place from my boyfriend who said that this particular bakery had the best french style dessert popularly named "thousand leaves". I decided to order the cake despite how far away it is from my house and when I got there a very police gentleman opened the door as I walked through and all the girls in the place were super sweet. They were all very helpful and polite. Later on that night I surpised my boyfriend with his favorite cake and to my surprise this cake was so delicious. The flaky layers were crisp and perfect. The chocolate and vanilla creme fillings were devine and the chocolate shavings on top of the cake simply melted in your mouth. All in all this cake was amazing and the people were sweet. I'll be sure to go back!

  • Pros: Known for their "Thousand Leaves" cake
  • Cons: none
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/29/08

The best around

by ryansmk37

Used to travel all the way back to my old neighborhood in the bronx until I found this place.

By far the best cookies and cakes around.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

12/20/07

Great hang out, espresso, gelatti, and cakes. The best italian bakery in the hood; one of the best in NY

by chanag

this is a real neighborhood hangout. I love this place. Great espresso and real Italian treats. I'm not sure what that other person was talking about regarding the gelatti, as far as NY is concerned their gelatti is pretty great. My favorite dessert is their plain large Ba ba; A rum soaked cake. So delicious. I have not tried their cakes but I will and I have a feeling it will make me very happy. Fortunato Bros. is a real Williamsburg hot spot, I feel very lucky to live three blocks away. Don't hesitate to try this place, its great.

  • Pros: people watching, quality, atmosphere, yummy and chill
  • Cons: service is a bit chaotic
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/23/07

i love it dare

by bellaxoxo

i <3 fortunantos so much ever thing there is so great it da best place in da world i love there lobster tails and conoli i love it ive been going there a since iwas little i <3 fortuantos

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/26/06

Amazing Mango Gillato

by fingerlickingkitten

I love this place, the mango gillato is amazing. As is the Black Forest Cake, the espresso, and the mocha cookie sandwich. The people watching is great too, stop by around 8 pm on any given night and there is always an interesting local crowd.

  • Pros: Gillato, Cake, Coffee
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

10/06/06

BEST CAKE EVER

by mickey_finn

My friend owns a shop in the area and she always gets the birthday cake there...hands down the most delicious cake ever! Real buttercream, real strawberries, real bananas (real fatty too, I'm sure) but well worth the risk. Love it.

  • Pros: Amazing cakes.
  • Cons: Far away from my house.
3.5 Star Rating: Average

03/11/04

This old-school caffe and pasticceria holds the generations of Williamsburg together with love and gelati.

by Karen Hudes

In Short
The shiny black tables and chairs in this bare bones cafe are perpetually packed with teen couples, old paisanos from the 'hood and ice cream afficianados diving into some of the city's best housemade gelato. Flavors range from standards to hard-to-find Italian options, like tiramisu, hazelnut and zuppa inglese. Other temptations include spumoni, tortoni, cannoli, cookies (try the pinoli), tarts and fluffy white cakes to order.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/07/02

like the old country!

by billburger

Best espresso. Can be served at the bar or in cafe!

3.5 Star Rating: Average

05/30/02

Gelato Downhill

by bklyn

This place used to have wonderful, intensely flavored gelato. No more. I suspect that they have begun to buy their gelato from a factory rather than making it themselves.

The coffees and the pastries are nice, however, and the atmosphere is wonderful.

Lists In Brooklyn

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Fortunato Brothers

Recent Reviews In Brooklyn

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Sugarcane

238 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Cebu

8801 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Anselmo's

354 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Frankies 457

457 Court St, Brooklyn, NY

Advertisement