(718) 222-0666

1 Main St
Brooklyn, NY 11201 40.7037 -73.9904

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Vinegar Hill

Reviews & Ratings for Bubby's Brooklyn

3.5 Star Rating: Average

26 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
1 Star Rating: Poor

08/02/09

DO NOT HAVE YOUR WEDDING HERE!

by kayteebugone

First of all, planning a wedding is hard enough but, one of, if not THE most important thing is to ensure that the reception food is delicious!

My fiance and I embarked on the arduous rite of passage of finding a reception venue for our wedding. After visiting many places, we stopped by Bubby's .

The prices are reasonable, the space was great-fun, big, two-levels with sweeping views of the Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges. We thought, great, let's have a tasting and then we can book the place. Here's the rub:

BUBBY'S ONLY OFFERS TASTINGS FOR WEDDING MENU ITEMS AFTER YOU PUT DOWN YOUR NON-REFUNDABLE DEPOSIT. We thought that was insane so, after a lot of back and forth we were able to secure an ENTREE tasting at a fee where we could sample entrees only from the wedding catering menu.

So, with fiance and father (he'll eat anything) in tow, we headed to Bubby's on a rainy Friday after work.

Once there, our waiter started bringing us the entree items one by one. The presentation was less than impressive with the food slapped in the center of the plate-no garnish, no sides...

First up: veggie lasagna

Review: had to be frozen. was cookie cutter lasagna, watery and without flavor

Next up: pecan crusted salmon

Review: overly sweetened crust to mask the blandness of the cat food like underside.

Lastly: Steak

The best of the three but, not good.

Don't get me wrong, the staff at Bubby's is really nice and the Brunch there is great BUT for something as important as your wedding-look elsewhere!

  • Pros: Spacious, Nice Views Affordable
  • Cons: THE FOOD IS AWFUL!!!
4 Star Rating: Recommended

08/25/08

Great food!

by lizzyred8

Great food - had gazpacho and flank steak...so yummy. Corn pudding is so good - like a dessert. I will definitely go back.

  • Pros: Great food!
3.5 Star Rating: Average

03/17/08

Family-friendly brunch and barbecue--plus homemade pie--in Dumbo

by Allison Austin

Bubby's original Tribeca location succeeded because of its oversized space, comfy vibe and the general quality of the food. The Dumbo location is even bigger, more comfortable and busier. Just steps from a waterfront park overlooking Manhattan, the converted warehouse is bright and spacious, with three offset levels of dining areas visible from the entrance and bar area. Because it's a family joint, servers, hosts and bartenders all exude folksy charm, and even when service is stretched a bit thin, things tend to work out fine. As in its sister restaurant, fluffy sourdough pancakes, thick, eggy french toast, decent fried chicken, and first-class desserts are the biggest draws.

3 Star Rating: Average

01/03/08

Decent Brunch...limited menu

by paule_10025

I had good memories of the place in Tribeca. The brunch menu was pretty limited...don't put up pictures of your mac and cheese then not have it on the menu! Apple and bacon omellette...solid. Only two pies available for dessert. Lame. They made us wait around for a while though there were open tables...a little annoying. Not a bad consolation prize if the line at Grimaldi's is too long.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

07/02/07

Cleaned up thier act!

by mwalker52

After a shaky past few months, I'm proud that Bubby's has taken the neighborhood's cries seriously and has made marked improvements. It's finally back to being a place I want to recommend to my friends!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/25/07

WOW

by dosita

This Bubby's is fantastic. The food is comforting and delicious. The view from this location cannot be beat. You must see it for yourself as the sun sets.

  • Pros: Best comfort food, gorgeous views
  • Cons: No cons at all!
1 Star Rating: Poor

04/10/07

WORSE EVERYTHING!!!

by gourmetexpert

Food: terrible for the $

Service: the worse ever. expect a forever wait for crappy food

deco: sucked (full of old junk)

DO NOT GO THERE

  • Pros: Nothing good
  • Cons: don't walk away...RUN AWAY
4 Star Rating: Recommended

03/11/07

Really good. Sweet service, great food, and worth the wait.

by roncrismon

My wife and I had an excellent brunch there today. There were lots of kids running around and our waiter was very patient with us. My wife is pregnant and has specific things she can't eat. They were very busy. It is surprising that the reviewer felt the need to post what he sais was their last health inspection. I went on line and saw their lasdt inspection, whcih had zero violations. Knowing what is going on in New York right now with the department of health, it seems like over-zealousness to attack a perfectly great restaurant. Whatever, the place is clean, and good.

  • Pros: Amazing view. Great brunch. Great barbecue.
  • Cons: Sometimes the wait.
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/04/07

Cheese grits!!!!!!!

by peanutbuttersandwich

If you have ever been so hung over from a crazy Saturday night, and were in such desperate need of an amazing brunch!! Bubby's in Brooklyn is the place to be!!! Not only was the service sweet and quick, but the food was amazing (order a bowl of cheese grits).....oh..did I mention the coffee. Best coffee ever and the server said it was free trade!!! I didn't save room for pie, but I know to next time!!!

  • Pros: Food, and service
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/02/07

Great party space

by ladybug888

We went to a wedding here recently and loved it! It was perfect for a large group- homey comfort food, not too fancy, but delicious. Loved the blue cheese dip and that cherry pie!! Excellent service. Better than the food is the space-- open and light. The view is unparalleled. Overally, for NYC, great for a party.

Showing 1-10 of 25 reviews

Lists In Brooklyn

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Bubby's Brooklyn

Recent Reviews In Brooklyn

1 Star Rating: Poor

My Moon

184 N 10th St, Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Bonnie's Grill

278 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

My Moon

184 N 10th St, Brooklyn, NY

1 Star Rating: Poor

Applebee's Neighborhood Grill

2505 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY

Advertisement