Nick's Lobster & Fish Market

(718) 253-7117

2777 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11234 40.6041 -73.916

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Mill Basin

Price:

$$$

What People Are Saying About Nick's Lobster & Fish Market

The Editor

Contributor

Citysearch

The title crustacean of this Brooklyn seafood restauarant and market shares star billing with the Marine Park views.

1 Star Rating: Poor

07/12/09

I was over it as soon as i walked in!!

by charr093 at Citysearch

I decided to take my parents out to dinner so i took them to NICKS. I thought it would be a nice dinner but it wasnt. As soon as we got there, we waited by the "please wait to be seated sign" however the man behind the counter just 2 feet away never looked in our direction.

One we were seated (20 mins later) the same man scratched his genitals and took 3 menus 2 sit us down. What a nice way to be greeted!

  • Cons: staff uniforms or lack there of
1 Star Rating: Poor

02/16/09

What has happened to this place?

by whung80 at Citysearch

Went there last night with family and the best thing that was brought to the table was the chicken tenders - for a 10 year old. The broiled fillet of sole was baked onto the plate - had to scrap the fish just to eat it. When it got to the table, there was all this water on the top - I have never seen a fillet of sole like this before. Other orders were a steak, a cheeseburger (both came out well done even though the waitress never asked how both should be cooked), fried shrimp (which was very greasy and bad), a baked lobster with "homemade" stuffing (the lobster had no meat in it, looked old and it was a waste to get the horrible stuffing), and a lobster tail scampi (I don't know where the chef learned to make scampi, but that was by far the worst I have seen and tasted). The waitress and service was horrible too - she came by to take the orders and never really came back other than to give us our meals. The bread and check we had to get from someone else. Too bad the tip was included on the bill - or else her tip would have been minimal. DO NOT GO HERE!!!

  • Pros: None
  • Cons: food, service, price
1 Star Rating: Poor

05/29/08

Where's The CRAB??????

by CeeSmith at Citysearch

I drive by every day and figured since the restaurant was connected to a fish market the seafood at the would be great, not so. I was unhappy with the service the waitress and the cashier were having their own long conversation while I was waiting to order. The menu was a sheet of paper that had been photo copied over and over and you could barely make out the words. Buy hey maybe this was their way of cutting cost. The coconut shrimps were over cooked and spongy and the crab cakes were hardly crab just filler, I am pretty sure whatever was in them was actually imitation. I was disappointed that I paid as much as I did for food that was not at all good. I would not recommend this place.

They do have a huge lobster in their firsh market tank though. I can't imagine what he would cost but he would make for good eating. But I would cook it myself.

  • Pros: Parking
  • Cons: Food is horrible.

The Details on Nick's Lobster & Fish Market

Category:

Restaurants, Butcher Shops, Seafood Markets

Payment Methods:

American Express, Discover, Visa, MasterCard

Restaurant Special Features:

Outdoor Dining, Waterfront Dining, View Dining

Cuisine:

Seafood

Lists In Brooklyn

Advertisement
Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Nick's Lobster & Fish Market

Nick's Lobster & Fish Market

2777 Flatbush Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11234

Recent Reviews In Brooklyn

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

La Piazzetta

442 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Pane E Vino

174 Smith St. , Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Patricia's Pizza and Pasta of Williamsburg

35 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Patricia's Pizza and Pasta of Williamsburg

35 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY

Advertisement