Scotti's Pizzeria (Reported Closed)

Recommends

JECLA

Joined 5 years ago

Amazing, traditional NY Pizza!. So I read the other 2 bad reviews and was shocked to hear how they rated this place. So I agree that the place doesn't have the best ambiance, but do they serve you a proper, delicious NY Pizza! I never had a problem with the people who work there--they always greet me with a great smile and love to put on a conversation.

The crust is thin, but not too thin---w/ a lovely sauce and delicious combo of cheese on top that makes this pizza truly fabulous. I have brought many of friends to this place and all have agreed this is their favorite NY Pizza! I've brought them to the famous ones as well (Grimaldi's, Lombardi's, Johns, Ray's, etc...) and this place beats them all.

I travel about 45 minutes now from Manhattan so I can eat there...and yes, it's totally worth the trip :)

Doesn't Recommend

CSMobileUser

Joined 5 years ago

garbage pizzeria. this place is a piece of dump the workers have attitudes and the food is stale and disgusting

Doesn't Recommend

s0okz

Joined 5 years ago

Worst pizza in Brooklyn. May very well be the worst pizza I've had in my 24 plus years inhabiting God's green earth. The guy who reviewed this before me probably works for the place or was inebriated when he wrote that. I can't speak about their other food, but their pizza was garbage. It tasted like it had been sitting there all day, and was reheated when we called. The crust tasted like sourdough pretzels, which was just disgusting in combination with the dried out cheese. I would have rather had "pizza" from Domino's or Papa John's (which I consider to be "cheesy tomato bread," rather than pizza). Do yourself a favor and call up pizza wagon (718-836-5725) or Maria's (718-745-9326) instead.

Recommends

lisac

Joined 10 years ago

Too good to be true!. By far the best pizza in NY! My entire family continues to enjoy Scotti's food after more than 25 years. Italians know their pizza!