save

Al Di La Trattoria

248 5TH Ave, Brooklyn, NY | Map it  

11215 40.675401 -73.981400

(718) 783-4565 | View Website

  • Hours

    Monday 12-3, 6-10:30 Tuesday 6-10:30 Wednesday 12-3, 6-10:30 Thursday 12-3, 6-10:30 Friday 12-3, 6-11 Saturday 10:30-3, 5:30-10:30 Sunday 10:30-3, 5-10:00
  • Share
4

out of 5

4 Star Rating: Recommended

83 Reviews

Sign in to Write a Review

My Rating

Features

Neighborhoods:
Park Slope
Price:
$$$
Cuisine:
Italian
Categories:
Restaurants

View More

Restaurant Special Features:
Notable Wine List, Romantic Dining
Payment Methods:
MasterCard, Visa

View Less

Review Highlights

ambiance
97%
“This place is really great--wonderful wine list, romantic ambiance, and best of all the food is amazing!”
dessert
100%
“And for desert, I never pass the Giandiuotto -- the best chocolate ice cream I ever had!”
drinks
77%
“The only problem is that they don't take reservations, but you can put your name on the list and head for the nice wine bar around the corner from the restaurant.”
food quality
89%
“The pasta and risotto is perfect.”
View More
menu variety
97%
“The tapas starter featured great shrimp, but the other tapas selections were nondescript.”
overall
87%
“Terrible staff ruin great restaurant”
return potential
75%
“The simplicity of the food is why I return, not to mention the amazing olive oil they import.”
service
76%
“reasonable, wonderful, consistent, dependable, always worth it, always romantic and fun, great service/staff, excellent wine choices, some of our favorite dishes (TRY the beet ravioli even though it sounds odd, it's fantastic, the cuddlefish risotto speci”
value
93%
“Walk in through a thick velvet curtain and find food that is pitch perfect (beet ravioli is sublime) at prices that are very reasonable - $10 to 18.”
wait time
50%
“mean really, in less than 5 minutes, the wine went from pettilant to full frizzante (we aren't talking about lambrusco here).” View Less

Reviews for Al Di La Trattoria

nyceater989

Member since Oct, 2010 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 2 years ago
5.0
October 17, 2010

Live's Up to the Hype. I've lived in Park Slope for years, but haven't been to al di la because of the long waits. Recently, however, they started opening up for Tuesday nights. I guess most people don't know about it, because the wait for a table at 8 was really short (just a few minutes). Anyway, the food lived up to the hype. I really dug the shabby-chic ambiance. The staff was courteous and professional. I have been missing out. Can't wait to go back (even if I have to wait).

View More View Less
0

mosley

Member since Jul, 2010 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 2 years ago
2.0
July 23, 2010

Maitre-D-"Eat and get out". My family ate here last weekend. The food and service were fine, however the maitre-D was incredibly unwelcoming and arrogant. While finishing our meals which included a high-end bottle of wine, our son's fiance joined us for a glass of wine and dessert. This guy refused to seat her and she left, followed shortly by the four of us, but not before I told him that in my 40 years of world travel, including Paris, that I had never seen such a display of bad behavior by a frontman in a restaurant. His response was smug, arrogant, and condescending, totally consistent with his deportment on display all evening. A word to the wise: you can't dine here and disturb the maitre-D's sense of " table turnover", as whacked as it is, or else. If you go here, do it on his off-night.

View More View Less
0

vene3000

Member since Mar, 2006 View Profile
9Reviews
0Photos
Joined 6 years ago
5.0
June 30, 2010

One of the Best In Brooklyn. I've always had great experiences coming here. Although they don't take reservations and I've had to wait 30-60 min at times, it's been worth the wait. The food is very good. Almost everything is sure to be a good pick. I recommend the sepia risotto or the ribs if they're available. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive. Can't say that I've had a better staff wait on me in Brooklyn, with the exception of River Cafe. If you're is looking for great Italian cuisine, or great food in general, this is a sure bet.

View More View Less
0

JaneC

Member since Dec, 2009 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 3 years ago
5.0
January 03, 2010

Love Al Di La. I recommend this place to everyone. Great food.

0

benwhit

Member since Nov, 2009 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 3 years ago
5.0
November 29, 2009

Lives up to the hype. We've lived around the corner from this place for over a year and finally had dinner there. We've tried before but it always packed and doesn't take reservations. It was well worth the wait. The wife had the risotto which was amazing. It doesn't look appetizing as it's covered in squid ink and it turns your lips and teeth black, but the taste was phenomenal. The farro salad and the mashed yukon potatoes were also extremely tasty.

View More View Less
0

See more reviews for Al Di La Trattoria

Things to do near Al Di La Trattoria