Great Lakes Bar & Restaurant

(718) 499-3710

284 5TH Ave Ste 497
Brooklyn, NY 11215 40.6738 -73.9823

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Park Slope

Last updated 4.01.09

Category:

Restaurants, Bars & Pubs, Neighborhood Bars, Bars & Clubs

Payment Methods:

Cash

Bar & Pub Special Features:

Jukebox

What People Are Saying About Great Lakes Bar & Restaurant

Featured Review

Contributor

Contributor

In Short – Save for the nod toward the Midwest for design inspiration (do the name, some maps of Lake Michigan and an outboard motor qualify it as a theme bar?), what stands out about an evening here is the overwhelming number of indie-rock classics you'll hear. The jukebox takes you way back to 1994, when Archers of Loaf were the bee's knees and Arlington, Virginia, was the place where dreams were made.

ambiance
100.0% positive
  1. anyway i liked the bar it was fun and the people seemed really nice.
drinks
90.0% positive
  1. Second that this is a great bar for music and beer lovers.
  2. this is a wonderful little bar, often with live music.
  3. anyway i liked the bar it was fun and the people seemed really nice.
  4. Someone wrote below me it's the best bar on 5th avenue.
  5. great little hangout for a casual drink -- or evening of drinks.
  6. rare bar that has no attitude just like it's name midwestern friendliness.
  7. Maybe in that order, not that the beer is bad, but the music stands out as being.
  8. Great tunes and skilled beauties behind the bar
  9. This was the best bar on 5th Ave. The junkebox was amazing, New York Dolls to
  10. the bar was awesome.
food quality
100.0% positive
  1. Fun people hang out there, amazing burgers down the block, and Great Lakes does a FREE burlesque show on the last Monday of every month from Jenny C'est Quoi, Magdalena Fox and Joe the Shark.
overall
100.0% positive
  1. great place
service
70.0% positive
  1. Terrible service
  2. Seriously, terrible service.
  3. Dark with high ceilings and an unbelievably awesome jukebox consisting mostly of mix cds made by the staff.
  4. anyway i liked the bar it was fun and the people seemed really nice.
  5. bartenders are great
  6. The staff was friendly and knew their music as well as thier customers.
  7. Probably the worst single bartender I've come across in nyc.
  8. Fun people hang out there, amazing burgers down the block, and Great Lakes does a FREE burlesque show on the last Monday of every month from Jenny C'est Quoi, Magdalena Fox and Joe the Shark.
  9. don't know what Racket's talking about, these are probably my favorite bartenders in all of Brooklyn.
  10. great bartender when i was there and great environment.
4 Star Rating: Recommended

12/18/09

Great tunes and skilled beauties behind the bar

by JoetheShark at Citysearch

Seriously, Great Lakes rocks. Fun people hang out there, amazing burgers down the block, and Great Lakes does a FREE burlesque show on the last Monday of every month from Jenny C'est Quoi, Magdalena Fox and Joe the Shark. What more could you ask for from a cool Brooklyn Bar?

  • Pros: Bartenders, music
  • Cons: No pool table
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/31/09

DRINKS ON THE HOUSE!!!!

by RonHorse at Citysearch

left my wallet at home the other night, thats cause i was on my way to Great Lakes. went for the first time a quarter of a month ago, didnt have to pay for ONE DRINK and its been the same the last eleven times ive been. the room is really dark which is good for the types of activities i care to engage in. the jukebox had about 80 percent of the mid-to-late 1800's chamber music i like, and again, i didnt have to pay for my selections. the bartender looks nervous and weak. he never remembers my middle name LOL. good luck ordering an ice cream cone btw. most importantly though YOU LITERALLY DONT HAVE TO PAY FOR THE DRINKS YOU ORDER AND ARE GIVEN TO YOU.

  • Pros: A LITTLE PRICEY LOL
  • Cons: was locked in the bathroom for 3 hours once
3 Star Rating: Average

04/25/08

m

by charliecompany at Citysearch

i've been going to this place for eight years and i don't really notice much of a change. the jukebox is still good, the bathroom is still nasty and they serve booze. i don't need a bartender to make me feel particularly welcome. they put up with enough garbage from park slope yuppies. i think you can cut em a break.

1 Star Rating: Poor

08/26/07

Most Unprofessional Barstaff

by devon7 at Citysearch

Avoid this place - the barstaff were Ill-mannered, not trained properly, monosyllabic, even cheat you on measures. Shame, as the jukebox is well-stacked, just the service is low-class.

  • Pros: The only pub I saw for a few blocks
  • Cons: Low-class barstaff, fake interior, small measures
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/20/07

I loved the joint

by rossgill at Citysearch

the bar was awesome. i happened to be there when the other person seemed to flip out at the girl working because she didn't get any free beers. it seemed sad and cheap.i found the girl bartending to be really nice and funny. i liked the place.

do people really complain about not getting something for free? i'm not from new york but to me that seems really strange and i would be humiliated if i was ever with someone who wasn't willing to pay for what they ordered.

anyway i liked the bar it was fun and the people seemed really nice. it was uncomfortable when this large woman was freaking out about not getting something for free but other than that i had a nice time. i haven't seen anyplace in this hood quite as comfy yet.

maybe its different here but i go out expecting to pay for my drinks. this woman who was shouting behind me was just a little crazy.... why would you be mean to someone because they didn't give you something for free?

The Details on Great Lakes Bar & Restaurant

Place Categories:

  • great place
  • unbelievably awesome jukebox
  • abysmal bathroom
  • terrible service
  • favorite bartenders
  • loved joint
  • even more happy god
  • cool brooklyn bar
  • worst single bartender
  • bad beer
  • wonderful little bar
  • amazing junkebox
  • great tunes
  • great environment
  • really nice people
  • great skilled beauties
  • cold comfort
  • decent folk
  • amazing burgers
  • best rare bar
  • friendly staff
  • great little hangout
Advertisement

Lists In Brooklyn

Recent Reviews In Brooklyn

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Monte's Restaurant

451 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY

3 Star Rating: Average

Sahara Restaurant

2337 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Mussel Pot

174 Bleecker St, New York, NY

Advertisement