save

Grimaldi's

19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY | Map it  

11201 40.703001 -73.994101

(718) 858-4300 | View Website

  • Hours

    Monday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Tuesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Wednesday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Thursday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Friday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Saturday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM Sunday 09:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Share
4

out of 5

4 Star Rating: Recommended

227 Reviews

Sign in to Write a Review

My Rating

Features

Neighborhoods:
Vinegar Hill
Cuisine:
Italian, Pizza
Price:
$
Categories:
Restaurants

View More

Restaurant Special Features:
Cheap Eats, Local Favorite, Group Dining, Family-Friendly Dining, Lunch Spot
Payment Methods:
Cash

View Less

Review Highlights

ambiance
90%
“The atmosphere is pretty cool really.”
dessert
100%
“Try Nino's on 3rd Ave for the best Granmama pie you'll ever taste; Krispy's on 13th Ave for superlative neopolitan pizza; L & B on 86th Street for great and unique sicilian.”
drinks
88%
“To drink, order a beer or soda but if you ask for wine, don't expect anything memorable.”
food quality
88%
“The ingredients are fresh, the sauce tangy and the cheese goopy.”
View More
menu variety
100%
“The pizza is crisp, flavorful and you can get a varied selection of ingredients, like fresh garlic, red peppers, and black olives.”
overall
96%
“The pizza here is so good that this place only takes cash!”
return potential
100%
“Can't wait to go back; this pizza was amazing!”
service
63%
“Very rude.”
value
84%
“Sure its in a cool location, but its not worth the price you pay.”
wait time
69%
“Really loved every minute of it!” View Less

Reviews for Grimaldi's

Briana786

Member since Jul, 2010 View Profile
7Reviews
0Photos
Joined 2 years ago
4.0
March 17, 2012

Good not great. The pizza is very good, but the attitude is so bad that I'd rather support establishments that make pizza that does not taste as good but puts at least some effort into customer service. For a list of the top 10 restaurants https://files.nyu.edu/jdy215/public

View More View Less
0

DanniD

Member since Jan, 2012 View Profile
2Reviews
0Photos
Joined 4 months ago
5.0
January 20, 2012

DEFINITELY stands up to the hype. My husband and I are pizza lovers, so naturally before visiting NYC from Australia, I did a little research about where to get the best pizza. Grimaldi's came up time and time again so I made sure it was on our agenda.

Such the perfect way to top off a walk across the Brooklyn bridge. The area in Brooklyn Heights has a real historic feel and fabulous for your senses, The Gramaldi building is an old bank and has a lot of character inside and out. When we walked in, we were surprised by how fresh and modern it was,

The pizza certainly didn't disappoint, it was EXACTLY what you would hope you pizza would taste like. The best part is that you get presented with a blank canvas to make your own pizza, so you are getting exactly what you want.

The service was fast but I didn't feel rushed. Not overly friendly... they let the pizza do the talking. The restaurant is CASH ONLY. I recommend the visit.

View More View Less
0

BrandiSK

Member since Jan, 2012 View Profile
3Reviews
0Photos
Joined 4 months ago
1.0
January 10, 2012

Ugh. The pizza crust tastes like flakeboard , the sauce tastes like Ragu, the crowd thinks its cool to be cattle, cell phone conversations are loud and abundant and the illegals make the pizza.

0

mitchlowes

Member since Dec, 2010 View Profile
1Review
0Photos
Joined 2 years ago
4.0
December 18, 2011

Great place to go!. Great place. Its busy, and jam packed during busy times, but the food is great and the people are friendly. they also keep things moving pretty quickly.

0

glori68

Member since Oct, 2011 View Profile
3Reviews
0Photos
Joined 7 months ago
5.0
October 12, 2011

MY BOYFRIEND HAS AN ADDICTION TO THIS PLACE!. "Let's go to Grimaldi's!" This statement is expressed to me from my boyfriend no less than 5 times a month. We live about 20 minutes from Grimaldis and there is SOME GOOD DARN PIZZA in our neighborhood and well, within a 5 minute drive or train ride of us and STILL he MUST go to Grimaldis... NEED I SAY MORE? LOL

View More View Less
0

See more reviews for Grimaldi's