Brooklyn Other Cities

Welcome to Citysearch!

Find what you were looking for? (Hint: You can use the search box in the upper left-hand corner to track down anything you want. We're here to help, so click around.)
 | close

My Summary

Recently viewed

Recommended for you

More

Chestnut

271 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11231
Phone: (718) 243-0049
Chestnut
Price:
$$$
Cross Street:
DeGraw Street
Directions:
F, G at Carroll St
Hours:
Tue-Sat 5:30pm-11pm, Sun 11am-3:30pm, 5:30pm-11pm

Editorial Review for Chestnut – by Erin Behan

The Scene
Uncomplicated, tasteful touches--a soothing abstract painting, an exposed brick wall, a tiny bar--grace the restaurant's neutral-toned interior. The adept waitstaff moves between the tightly packed tables, delivering plates of rich, hearty fare to the neighborhood's 30-something gastronomes and oenophiles.

The Food
Former Chef of Washington Park Daniel Eardley leans heavily on seasonal ingredients: An autumn appetizer of duck salad bursts with ripe pomegranate seeds; tender grilled octopus with peppers and turnips is a starter must for every table. Entrees continue the theme, employing earthy ingredients, often in unconventional ways. Spaghetti, tossed with gorgonzola, cabbage and celery root, packs an uncharacteristic bite, and the ample ribeye is nicely spiced by the subtly sweet onion jam. Desserts, such as apple quince pie and chocolate cake, are good enough, but don't merit the loosening of a belt buckle. Instead finish with the fragrant peppermint tea, which arrives in an individual French press.

Editorial content is independent of paid advertisers. Any expenses are paid for by Citysearch.

Insider Tips

What to Drink

The wine list does not play geographical favorites--wines from France, Oregon, Switzerland, Italy and Washington all make the list. Feeling confused? The house syrah is a good pick.

Know Before You Go

A smaller late-night menu is served from 11pm to 1am on Sunday, Tuesday and Wednesday, and from 11pm to 3am Thursday through Saturday.

Where to Sit

When making reservations, be sure to request a table far away from the swinging kitchen door.

User Reviews for Chestnut

1 Star Rating: Not Recommended

07/13/2008 Posted by happyjuice8000

I used to love this place. They used to have good food and good service. However, this place has gone downhill very fast. I suspect there is new management or new kitchen staff. The usual winners on their menu have rapidly turned into losers. Their pasta dishes, once excellent, are now mushy messes. They taste like re-heated over-cooked pasta that's been sitting out all day. Their veggies are now over-cooked and over-salted. Their chicken is now so dry you have to choke it down with their off-tasting tap water. Their wines by the glass, though pricey, often taste like they've been poured out of large economy-sized bottles or boxes sitting in the fridge for weeks. They taste completely oxidized, like when you open a bottle of wine, keep it in your fridge with a poor fitting cork and try to drink it again a couple weeks later. The floors and tables are sticky and smell shockingly foul, like they've been washed with filthy mops and rags (the same ones used to clean the bathroom). Needless to say, the bathroom is dirty, and the thought of the kitchen staff washing their hands in there is revolting. While most of the waitstaff is pleasant, the manager is dismissive, and there is one waitress who is pushy and rude and condescending. Don't waste your hard-earned money at this place.

Pros: Used to have good food and service.

Cons: Food and cleanliness has gotten really bad.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/04/2008 Posted by segale

This is one of the greatest meals in Brooklyn. The service is great, and the food is creative and always amazing. The ice cream dessert is by far the best in the city.

Users Like You Also Viewed

5 Ninth
5 9th Ave
New York, NY 10014-1501

The E.U.
235 E 4th St
New York, NY 10009

Related Searches

Editor's Review

Simple, rustic, casually elegant: The dining room and cuisine share common ground at this Smith Street eatery.  See the full editorial review.

Insider Tips

What to Drink

The wine list does not play geographical favorites--wines from France, Oregon, Switzerland, Italy and Washington all make the list. Feeling confused? The house syrah is a good pick.

More Insider Tips

Restaurant Information

Hours

  • Tue-Sat 5:30pm-11pm
  • Sun 11am-3:30pm, 5:30pm-11pm

Dress Code

  • Casual

Cuisines

  • American (Traditional)
  • American (New)

Payment Types

  • Visa
  • MasterCard

Meal Price

  • $$$

Amenities

  • Prix Fixe Menus
  • Dine at the Bar
  • Notable Wine List
  • People Watching
  • Brunch
  • Kid Friendly
  • Romantic Dining

Site Links:

Citysearch is a registered trademark of Bluefoot Ventures Inc., and is used under license.
© 2008 Citysearch.com All rights reserved.

Partner Sites: