(718) 832-1599
390 5th Ave
Brooklyn,
NY
11215
40.6709
-73.9852
Neighborhood: Park Slope
Last updated 11.15.09
Category:
Bars & Pubs, Gay & Lesbian Bars, Neighborhood Bars, Bars & Clubs, Taverns
What People Are Saying About Excelsior
Featured Review
Contributor
Contributor
In Short – Excelsior's crimson walls reflect cheer onto clients' rosy complexions, creating a warm, welcoming vibe. The stylish decor falls somewhere between art deco and pure '70s, with yellow gumdrop lights overhanging a wide mahogany bar. Brooklyn still doesn't move as fast as Manhattan, so this scene isn't quite as cruisy. In fact, Excelsior feels in many ways like a casual dating service for outerborough gay men.
Editor's Tips
- The Extras:
- There's also a jukebox and a small outdoor deck, perfect for enjoying sunny days.
| ambiance | 100.0% positive |
|
|---|---|---|
| drinks | 87.5% positive |
|
| service | 60.0% positive |
|
Boring and Bacterial
by JBJBJB
I'm new to Brooklyn and went tonight after work to meet a friend who has been there before. I arrived before my friend and found only one other customer. When I joked about this to the bartender his response was "it's only six o'clock" but his tone was not warm and fuzzy at all. Well pardon me Mr. Attitude, but okay.
Then as I ordered my drink, he removed a piece of fruit he'd had in his mouth (lemon?) and squeezed three juicy little pits in to his fingertips and threw them away. He then grabbed a bar towel and wiped off his hands before starting my drink.
This was disgusting behavior to begin with and any food or drink service professional would know to wash their hands well before continuing to serve. I debated saying something as he made the drink but instead just told him to skip the twist - I didn't want anything he'd touched in my glass.
As I drank it, I watched him cut up the rest of the evening's lemon and lime wedges which he handled freely - in fact excessively - still having not washed his hands after the pit incident and handling my money. I won't even elaborate any more on the snotty attitude of this bartender or the lack of charm in this place.
While my friend and I were there a few apparent regulars arrived to whom the bartender issued a hearty greeting. Perhaps he should share that same warmth with potential NEW regulars as I might have become but instead I am certain I'll never return.
Best gay bar in NYC
by BKbubble
The crowd here is no attitude and friendly, which is why it's so easy to get laid here. Great place in the summer, since they have a garden in the back.
- Pros: Great jukebox, super friendly staff, cute guys
GHETTOY attitude bar owners & bartenders
by isyisy
This place should be shut down for what they do to customers. I've seen polices breaking up the fights and other things......
- Cons: attitudes of bartenders & owners
Fight Fight Fight
by Supesfan11215
This place is a wild mixture of mind numbing boredom or freaking bar room brawls. There was a glass smashing, rolling out the front door fight last night. It continued on the side walk with the bar staff beating down a patron, said patron coming back half an hr later and threatening to smash down the glass front door. Needless to say there was much clutching of pearls going on all night.
The police arrived a few times and the wild night seemed to settle down. This was apparently the 2nd fight in as many days. It was almost like being at Cattyshack. Me-ow!
- Pros: There's always a different vibe
- Cons: Sometimes the vibe is Fight Club!
Fun At Times
by mark11215
This place can be fun. Yes, it's cliquey but what gay bar isn't?
The only problem is like the rest of the hood, it can be too bland.
Very samey samey at times.
But you can meet some interesting people after a few drinks.
Also a good place to viciously rip people apart for a few hours.
- Pros: Local. Great for stumbling home from
- Cons: Jukebox has NO Madonna!!!
The Details on Excelsior
Place Categories:
- rude bartenders
- very nice garden
- chatty clientele
- still divine drinks
- rude unbelievably
- terrible excelsior
- great service
- great neighborhood hangout
- great outdoor deck
- good crowd
- great neighborhood
- great juke box
- always really fun jukebox
- fun place
- friendly bar staff
- great neighborhood bar
- interesting people

